
Beached fishing draggers possibly at Shirt Tail Point. Shirt Tail Point was dredged to make way for the Wellfleet Marina. Photo from Wellfleet Historical Society collection.
By Doreen Leggett
On a wall in a back room of the Wellfleet Historical Society hangs a map with locations of dozens of homes and businesses that lined Commercial Street in the 1800s and early 1900s.
The vast majority connected to the fisheries.
The Bradford Apartments were built for seamen and their families in the 1840s. The home of James Swett, mackerel fisherman, mid-1800s. Nehemiah Baker, a seaman, 1860. James Mott, ship caulker, 1864. Jeremiah Freeman, a mariner, 1860s. J. Chipman, fish packer,1870. Captain Freeman Atkins Snow, agent for Commercial Wharf Co., 1890s. The DeLory brothers, famous for the number of quahogs they could dig in a day, 1909.
The other side of the street: Henry Rogers, Duck Creek Shipyard, 1848. Noah Swett, fish inspector, 1860. Edwin Lamson, manager of Wellfleet Oyster Co., 1920.
In his paper on the town’s mackerel fishery during the 1860s, David Balch noted a successful trip could earn each crew member about $90—enough to buy a share in a fishing vessel for $50 to $60. Buildable land sold for approximately $10 to $15 an acre, and a house cost between $500 and $600. As Balch’s figures show, a few good fishing trips could put modest property ownership within reach for many fishermen.
On a schooner each man had his own barrel (or barrels) to fill and was paid by what he caught (after the captain’s share was removed). Balch wrote that 74 percent of propertied men had jobs linked to mackerel.
Balch also noted the religious influence on the town. Wellfleet fishermen were called “Biblebacks” and described their reluctance to fish on Sundays, preferring to “lay off windward,” “praying and singing hymns,” allowing themselves to drift through the fleet snarling nets, lines and other gear.
While at its height in the 1860s, the industry started long before. Levi Whitman, a minister in Wellfleet in the late 1700s and early 1800s and an amateur historian, reportedly said, “There are few towns so well supplied with fish of all kinds as Wellfleet and no part of the world has better oysters.” In 1802, Wellfleet had 25 vessels: five whaling, four cod and mackerel fishing, four carrying oysters to the eastern coastal towns, and 12 fishing inshore waters.
The success of the fisheries bred associated industries. In 1837 there were 39 establishments for manufacturing salt and 10,000 bushels were made. Sail-making grew. In South Wellfleet, a central hub known simply as “the store” supplied mariners with clothing and provisions while offering loans and extending credit—akin to the general store in a mining town.
David Wright, curator at the Wellfleet Historical Society and Museum and author of “The Famous Beds of Wellfleet: A Shellfishing History,” said that although Wellfleet is now famous for oysters it was built by mackerel money.
“All the houses you see on Main Street that are nicer are a reflection of that mackerel money,” Wright said, sitting in the museum on Commercial Street on a bright sunny day a week before the town would be filled with thousands of people celebrating Oysterfest.
By 1851, Wellfleet was home to 79 vessels targeting mackerel. Those vessels employed 832 crew, more than a third of the entire town, impressive for a six-month fishery. Other Cape towns weren’t far behind; Provincetown had 61 mackerel boats, Truro 52, Harwich 48.
State landings reported at the time underscore the importance of the industry: 330,000 barrels of mackerel were brought home from 1850 to 1851. A standard barrel was about 40 gallons, creating a total of 13.2 million gallons.
The strong cash flow was a welcome turnaround from the town’s precarious position after the Revolutionary War. Before the British blockaded the Eastern Seaboard, Wellfleet had a healthy whaling industry with 420 plying the trade, but those boats were left to rot on the shore during the war.
When America won its independence whaling techniques had advanced to favor deep-water ports such as Nantucket, said Wright. The shallow harbor of Wellfleet was left behind.
Finfishing for cod, mackerel, and seining seemed the best way to adapt. The town centralized around Duck Creek where wharves and stores were built.
Finfishing transitioned to shellfishing when the railroad was built in 1870, its trestle cutting off Duck Creek, Wright said.
But mackerel remained strong. To foster the industry, Mercantile Wharf was purchased by Captain Lorenzo Dow Baker, Wellfleet’s famous native son who later started what became United Fruit, the forerunner to the Chiquita banana company.
He rebuilt the pier for mackerel and also erected one of the Cape’s first luxury inns, the 62-room Chequesett, which opened around 1886.
Baker and mackerel also set the stage for the town’s oyster industry. Oysters had been plentiful up until 1770 but disappeared due to overharvesting, ice — or a curse, depending on who you talk to.
One of Dow’s last contributions was in 1902 when he created the Massachusetts Department of Fisheries Shellfish Laboratory and Quahog Hatchery also on Mercantile Wharf. That lab was where David Belding began groundbreaking research that would revolutionize modern aquaculture, and keep the town linked to the shore.
